Disclaimer: within
this letter, I make references to church, ministries and religion. I do not
make any of these references by name. This letter is not intended to speak ill
of anyone, to blame anyone or to be used as evidence against any particular
people or organizations. I have had the great experience of being a part of
many organizations and churches that provided love, support, friendship and
community during so many times in my life. I am not anti-God or anti-church. In fact, I was in church on Sunday and loved being there. This is my experience. That is all
it is intended for.
Hello my friends. Some of you, I have known for as long as I
can remember and some of you have only recently come into my life. I have
always considered myself to be so fortunate that despite the many times my
family and myself have moved or transferred or started over, I still have
people around the world who care deeply for me.
The last 5 years have been a lot. I don’t even know if there
are words for the amount of heartache and change and joy and growth that I have
experienced since I graduated college. I have let go of dreams and embraced all
new ones. I have changed plans, made course corrections, had crushes and thought I was in love a few times, picked up habits and broken them. I have gained and lost friends. I have
forgiven and I have held grudges. I have changed my mind, switched sides,
flipped loyalties, and outgrown my old opinions. I don’t see this as a betrayal
to myself but rather an effort to continually grow, learn and embrace.
Changing, admitting you’re wrong and grieving your mistakes is not about
denying yourself or who you were, but rather allowing the full you, the real
you to continue to thrive and to always break through to the surface.
That is what I have done. I have faced every change and
every trauma and every heartbreak. I haven’t done it all perfectly. I can’t say
that I haven’t left casualties in the wake of my grief. I can’t say that I
never grew angry and that hatred never became my motivation because it did. I
have been angry and I have been hurt and I have been truthful and I have been
miserable and I have been wrong and above all, I have been myself. I have
always, always been the most honest version of myself that I could. For that I
am proud.
Many people have watched this journey. I somehow manage to
be a private person who tells everyone everything. I usually face every change
with a season of withdrawal and reflection before once again emerging fully
confident in the person I am, unashamed of all the words I have to say. I know
I’m probably getting it wrong most of the time but I would rather be wrong. I
would rather get it all wrong and make messes that need to be cleaned up than
live in a tidy world of being afraid of making a mistake. My mistakes have been
many and my sorrows considerable but the overwhelming confidence I feel is
undeniable.
Here I am at a new season of change. One that has been
coming for a very, very long time and one for which I am relieved is finally
here. I have spent my entire life, childhood and adulthood believing in the
traditional Christian values as they have been taught to me. I have had so many
beautiful experiences in the name of that faith and in the pursuit of that
life. I have also faced significant rejection and heartache as I have stumbled
through my twenties, desperately trying to understand what being a kind,
loving, open, changeable, truthful, normal, vulnerable, strong human means.
Along with many of the commonly taught principles of the
Christian faith, I for a long time have believed that homosexuality and same
sex attraction were sins. They were struggles some were plighted with, all were
susceptible to but everyone could overcome. This is something I now know so
emphatically in my heart to be false. I
cannot express my sorrow for all of the ways I unknowingly and blindly
contributed to the repression, rejection and suffering of so many people.
I had always, always been sensitive to the suffering of
people around the world. Hunger, war, disease, lack of education and access in
Third World countries would drive me to tears as a child. It was not until I
went to college and began studying social work that my eyes became opened to
the systematic, built-in injustices that we have created in my own country and
the ways that my religion has contributed to those things, no matter what the
intentions were. In was then that my heart towards the LGBTQ community began to
grow and I just barely started looking at things I was being taught. However,
like most things that poke at the foundation we have built our identity on,
this was far too painful to truly examine. If the church could be so obviously
wrong about this. If I could have been so, so plainly wrong about this, what
else, what other “truths” that I had spent my whole life clinging to could also
be so, so wrong. It was realty too painful to examine with any amount of truth
so shoved the questions deep inside myself until it became a wound of betrayal,
festering in its desperate attempt for air.
Like all festering wounds, this could not be ignored. So I
would reexamine this. I would dress it up and present it in a new way that
allowed me to love people the way I desperately wanted to without feeling like
I was betraying what I had been raised to believe. I twisted it so I could feel
justified holding onto my idea of being a Christian because that was something I
simply did not know how to let go of. I twisted myself and my thoughts and my
desires and my ideas into a shape that would fit the Christian size hole that
barred the entrance to the community and family and identity I had always
known. That hole never used to feel small or confining. When I was a child, I
passed through that hole with ease. Like walking into the church building on a
Sunday morning, the doors were wide open to me but as I grew, the hole became
smaller and more defined and more confined until I had contort myself into an
unrecognizable shape in order to fit through. Like a messed up game of Alice in
Wonderland where the fate of your very immortal soul in this life and the next
was all dependent on how well you could make yourself fit.
Not everyone seemed to be struggling with this ever shrinking
hole of acceptance. In fact, for some people it felt as if the older they got
and the more time went on, the wider the hole became, the more accepted their
shapes were. This religion made room for their growth and their gain. I watched
with envy as the friends I knew continued to walk through the doors and cried
myself to sleep as I began to realize what worked for them would never, ever
work for me. It wasn’t that I didn’t want to fit and didn’t want to follow the
rules and didn’t want to be everything I was “supposed” to be. I wanted to do
all of those things. I tried for years to be all of those things. But something
inside of me simply could no longer fold itself up into something that it
wasn’t. The cost of making myself into a convenient package for others was
losing parts of myself. Fitting into the ideas of my religion I had always
believed was like standing in front a tiny church looking in at the half-maimed
people inside. “It’s okay,” they said, “You don’t need both arms. Just chop off
a limb or two and you will fit in just fine.” How sad that no one ever told
them they could make a bigger door.
I am going to take a moment here to say something that
needs to be said. This overwhelming feeling of not being able to fit was not
the result of things other people had said to me. I was never verbally rejected
or told that I did not belong. In fact a lot of people have probably been
confused on why I pulled back so much, which is why I am here, writing this
letter. I have been very, very, very loved and I am very, very, very grateful.
I have spent the last twelve months standing on the outside
of that door, that hole, looking in. Confused at why I don’t fit anymore.
Desperate in my attempt to figure out what is so wrong with me. “Why isn’t this
working anymore?”, was the desperate scream inside my head. Begging the void to
answer me. The thing is, I am not angry. I have not been bitter. I have been so
very sad. And then it happened, the true break. When I was faced with the
decision to choose a side and I did. What caused this final break? A friend of
mine was told he could not be on church leadership because he was gay.
He is gay and he loves Jesus. He is gay and is single. He is
gay and he has been doing everything he can to stay within the rules so he can
fit in the hole; so he can get through the door. And because of who he was, he was told that
he could not participate. That he could not offer his praises and his songs and
his service and his sacrifice to the Lord. I was leading a ministry that I had
started at the time that was connected to a church and because of this, my
friend never asked if he could participate because he assumed my answer would
be the same, “No, we don’t have a space for your kind”. When I found this out,
I was distraught and heart broken. I wept. I wept for many days.
I kept my struggles to myself and did not share them with
very many. To stand up for the victimized sometimes means to become a victim
yourself and I was too afraid to face the rejection of being pro LGBTQ and pro God and pro church. So for a while I said nothing and all of these
feelings and thoughts and hurts and doubts stirred inside as I wrestled with
what kind of human I wanted to be. The kind who would say nothing or the kind
who would say everything.
I stepped down from church leadership a few months ago. It
was devastating for a time but has healed itself slowly. I was so saddened by
my need to leave but resolute in the conviction that I could not be a part of
something that didn’t make room for everyone. And I mean everyone. At first I
kept quiet about my reasons for stepping down and stepping away. I would share
half-truths about the reasons I left. Partly because I was afraid of the
rejection I would face and partly because I didn’t know what to do with the
painful looks back on the faces of those who loved me but didn’t know how to
love my ideas. I am not very good at staying silent so of course the real
reasons and my anger and my frustrations have been making their way to the
surface as I have been sorting through the voices crowding my own head about
what is and is not a sin and what sin even means and who God actually is and
what it actually means to be loved by Him.
So I pulled away, as I normally do. I stopped going to
church. Not because I didn’t want to go or because I didn’t want to believe but
because I was so tired of feeling like shit all of the time. Because I just
wanted to be happy and not have to worry about not fitting or what I was
standing for or against and because I was just so tired.
In the months since I stopped going to church, I have
discovered a lot of things. First of all, I love sleeping in on Sunday
mornings. Seriously glorious. Secondly, I discovered a whole group of people
who are amazing and who want to talk about real things like sex and fears and
that shit that happens in the world. And I really like these people. And
lastly, I have finally, finally let myself say out loud and admit to what I
have always known. I am gay.
After months of therapy and tears and panicking feelings of
trying to figure out why going on dates left me feeling petrified and why I
could never stomach the idea of intimacy with a man or why after spending my
whole life within a system I couldn’t fit anymore, I realized that I had been
miserably trying to force myself to do something that I couldn’t do; that I
would never be able to do. And the relief of this revelation is indescribable.
I am gay and I’m so freaking ecstatic. For the first time in
I don’t know how long, a future with someone actually seems possible. Love
actually seems possible. Marriage actually seems possible. I had long resigned
myself to single life because the sick feeling in my stomach I got whenever I
tried to date a man was such an anguishing feeling, I simply couldn’t do it
anymore.
I’m gay and I’ve never been prouder of myself. The day I
came out, I wept with such joy and such freedom. I felt God in my tears. I felt
God in my freedom. I felt God in the sweet, sweet redeeming feeling that there
was nothing wrong with me. That I didn’t need to fit into anymore holes or anymore
doors or anymore more systems or religions or churches or groups that need me
to shut down a part of who I am to appease their best interpretation of what
“goodness” looks like.
For those of you who are shocked or saddened by this news, I
wish I could tell you I was sorry. But I am not. I’m not sorry. I can tell you
that my wish for you is that whatever you choose to believe, you believe so
with your eyes wide open, conscious to the consequences. My wish for you is
that you might feel the depth of my love and gratitude for you on the part you
have played in my journey so far. My wish for you is that wherever you are
reading this, you find comfort and joy in knowing that you are not responsible
for me or the choices I have made.
I don’t owe you an explanation. I don’t owe anyone
explanation. I don’t owe you my story and I have no plans on giving you those
details. I am not interested in giving you the gory details of “how I know” or
“when I found out” because quite frankly, that is none of your damn business.
So I don’t offer this letter as an explanation but rather an invitation. An
invitation for you to explore all of the reasons within your heart that you
believe the things you believe.
I am gay. And I am so happy and so proud and so relieved.
You will always have my support hun! I know we have lost touch over the years but you have been one person that I have told happy stories with during my teen years. I support you and I am very happy to hear you are so happy coming out. If you need to talk I am here! Love maddie!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much! I really appreciate it :)
DeleteHope you are loved by Bob and Rachelle no matter what :-) you dear soul.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your kind words! I appreciate it
ReplyDelete